Welches Fahrrad zu kaufen? GIANT ATX 2 27.5" vs CTM RAMBLER 1.0 29"

Dear all,

First of all, I am sorry that I cannot explain my situation in German (Not that good at German yet). I am planning to buy a MTB (beginner level) and ended up with two options.

1. http://www.bikester.at/giant-atx-2-275-469055.html

2. http://www.fahrraddiscounter.at/mountainbikes/hardtail-mountainbikes-29-/03570-rambler-1.0-hellblau?number=03573

The Giant one has got a better fork in my opinion; however, I didn't read nice reviews about the Tektro mechnaical disc brakes it has. On the other hand the CTM bike has a better brakes but worse fork than the Giant one. My budget is around 400 euros. Which one would you prefer ? Or are there any other alternatives you could suggest ?

Thanks a lot.

Serhat

Hi Serhat,

First of all it would be interesting in which terrain you are planning to ride your bike? Usually, bikes around 400€ are not the best choice for "real mountainbiking".

Hi Stefan,

Thanks for your reply. I am planning to hit the terrains around Vienna in the beginning. Which can be found here: http://www.bergfex.at/sommer/wien-stadt/touren/mountainbike/

I don't really want to get something for professional at the moment, as I will just start riding on those kinds of terrains. In the future I might consider of getting a professional one, but at the moment I really just want to limit myself to max 500euro.

Thanks,

Serhat

Hi Serhat,

Considering this, it might be better to buy a used bike - have you thought of that option? You can check the "Börse" here or sites like willhaben.at for offers!

I actually didn't check them. Thanks for the tips, I'll definitely have a look! What is your opinion in general about those 2 new ones ?

Thanks.

Well the main difference is the wheelsize, 27,5" vs. 29" and you really have to check for yourself which one you prefer - both have their advantages. Honestly I've never heard about CTM as a brand and as the components are quite on a similar level I'd prefer the Giant. But as I said before, both are not the best choice for real mountain biking!

BTW: if you spend a little more, maybe this one will make you happy -> http://www.radon-bikes.de/bikes-2016/mountainbike/hardtail/zr-team-275/zr-team-275-60/

As Stefan said, it is very advisable to look into used bikes at this price tag.

You will some used MTB in very good condition for 400-500€ which really deserves the name "mountain bike".

What`s your height?

Hi,

I am 186cm, and inside leg measurement is around 87-88cm.

Hi Stefan,

Thanks for your replies, they have been really helpful. I have got 2 other models which are quite similar to the Radon one you have recommend. (I have decided to increase my budget a lil bit and get the one you recommended or one of those 2 other ones).

Giant: http://www.bikester.at/giant-talon-3-ltd-275-charcoalgrey-467719.html

Cube: http://www.bikester.at/cube-analog-greynblue-467373.html

What do you think of those two models ? According to bikeadviser Suntour XCR fork is better than rockshox XC30: http://www.bike-advisor.com/bicycle-guides/budget-cross-country-forks-for-your-bike.html

Besides, I have been thinking of getting a 29er as I am a bit tall (186cm).

Thanks a lot,

Serhat